Thursday, November 20, 2008

WTF Congress? Don't you want anybody to have a job??

Okay so I don't want to use this blog to debate politics or agendas or anything like that. But because of the events of this past week, I feel that I must. For those of you that read this blog that don't live in Michigan, I hope you can understand.

The auto industry is the life of this state. People give the American Auto manufacturers a lot of flack for having crappy products, not evolving fast enough, etc, etc. The arguments go on. What those people fail to realize is that a lot of those rumors are lies. Additionally these auto companies have provided an entire lifestyle to myself and my family for my entire life. I guess I am just frustrated b/c of the lack of facts that people actually know. I hear a lot of people saying "Well just let them go down". But this week I read that the NATIONWIDE unemployment rate will jump to 10% if something happens to one of the big three.
I read this article in today's Detroit News..
O'Connor: If the Big 3 suffer, we all suffer-Detroit News
Auto jobs are heavily linked to other employment across U.S.
If all the economists in the world were laid end to end, it's been said, they'd never reach a conclusion -- but one thing they do agree on is that should Detroit's Big Three continue to suffer, the U.S. economy will, too.
As federal policy makers weigh the overall economic cost of denying automakers federal loans and leave them to fend for themselves, they also must try to assess the job losses that would come if one or more of the Big Three shut their doors.
Whether the numbers prove that 1 out of every 10 U.S. jobs or 1 out of 80 is touched by Detroit automakers is irrelevant, says Dana Johnson, economist for Dallas-based Comerica bank. The important thing is, it's a lot.
"I would say 100 jobs out of 100 are touched," Johnson says. "It's an economy that's integrated, it's linked. What happens to your neighbor happens to you."

Ann Arbor's Center for Automotive Research estimates that 3 million jobs would be lost if General Motors Corp., Chrysler LLC and Ford Motor Co. shut their doors. At Moody's Economy.com. the total is estimated to be 2.6 million.
Po-TAY-toh. Po-TAH-toh.
Crunch the numbers about whose job gets crunched in an auto industry collapse, and it doesn't matter whether the data comes from an industry think-tank or a national research firm.
Either way, it's about 2 percent of all nonfarm jobs in the country and equals, on average, the 2.8 million workers who've lost their jobs in the past 12 months. Stop and consider that those workers came from all walks of life, including the mortgage meltdown and the Wall Street crash, and that the total job loss has been enough to send the U.S. economy teetering on the brink of recession.
Now add in a total collapse of the domestic auto industry, and it doubles.
But the real question isn't whether the entire U.S. auto industry will collapse -- it's what happens if just a part of it collapses, such as the liquidation of Chrysler or the bankruptcy of GM. The problem in estimating the damage is how to measure the ripple effects. For all their economic influence, Detroit's Big Three themselves employ only a small portion of the20workers engaged in the U.S. auto industry.
Direct employees who get a paycheck (for now at least) from GM, Ford or Chrysler total only 255,109, according to Moody's. That's only about one-third of the 767,000 people working to sell those cars at U.S. auto dealers. Those workers, in turn, are just part of the 2.3 million people indirectly employed by the Big Three, including auto suppliers.
All told, the direct and indirect jobs add up to 1.9 percent of the total U.S. work force, notes Sophia Koropeckyj, managing director of Moody's Economy.com.
"It's about nine indirect jobs for every one direct job," Koropeckyj said. That includes not just the supply chain for automakers but also the spending of the relatively well-paid autoworkers at a coffee shop near a factory or a lunch spot near corporate headquarters.
That figure doesn't include what's called "spillover" work at auto repair shops, parts stores, tire dealers and other car-related services that would continue in business if an automaker fails. The idea is that even if your Buick is orphaned by a failed GM, you'll still get the oil changed.
"The actual indirect jobs for the entire auto industry are much larger than this 2.3 million," Koropeckyj said. "But they will not all go away."
But that doesn't mean some spillover jobs aren't hurt by an automaker shutting down, notes Susan Helper, a professor of economics Case Western Reserve University in Cleveland w ho specializes in the auto industry. Even if you're still getting your oil changed, a laid-off GM worker is probably changing his own instead of hitting Quick Lube.
"The spillover is when the GM worker has less income and they are buying less coffee and fewer clothes and things like that," Helper said.
Judging from how job loss affects spending in past recessions, she estimates that the equivalent of something between 0.4 and 1 spillover job exists for each auto job.
At best, Helper estimates job losses of 500,000 if GM was liquidated, still enough to risk sending the foundering U.S. economy from recession into depression -- partly because no one really knows just how deeply the roots of the U.S. automakers go into the rest of the national economy.
At worst, she estimates, the failure of GM could lead to 1.5 million or even 2 million jobs lost.
One problem is gauging how much damage would happen to suppliers who make parts for more than one automaker. GM, Chrysler or Ford could make up two-thirds of a supplier's business, but the loss of those orders is more than enough to doom the entire shop.
"There is a risk of system because we really don't know the overlap in the supplier base and we know suppliers are on the edge financially, and it wouldn't take much to push them over," Helper says. The ongoing credit crunch also would threaten the ability of a supplier to survive a big loss in orders from a troubled carmaker, as well as making it harder for the unemployed workers to find new jobs.
"The auto industry is a big important industry -- there's no question about it," Comerica's Johnson said. "You don't want to say the whole economy depends on the auto sector, but there's no question that if you had a sudden shutdown of a major car company that would spill over and be of concern to the rest of the economy."
The only real question, as all the economists point out, is just how bad things would get. Let's hope we don't find out.


Now to be fair, I do work for a GM supplier, my Dad works for GM and I've always worked a piece of GM business. But I post this b/c I feel the sentiments are exactly the same for Chrysler and Ford too. We need to act. We need to stand up for ourselves and stop letting our politicians decide the fate of our country. If we don't we will loose all our jobs to 'backoffices' and outsourcing.

So this brings me to my next part of my post. An email sent to me by a good friend who shall remain nameless, but who I deeply respect. She is a GM employee. I hope this helps you understand from her perspective how GM employees are feeling.

"It is very sad to repeatedly hear of politicians, journalists, etc. who are so ignorant of the changes GM has made in the past decade and beyond. Regrettably GM has NOT done a good job of informing the world and it is very obvious that the public mind-set is 30+ years behind the times. It is most disturbing coming from Romney in view of his dad's connection to the industry. One would hope his roots would compel him to some level of support. Perhaps he is anti Union and does not know that GM has accomplished in recent years.

He refers to "retiree burdens". I can't help but wonder what his so-called restructuring would involve for the people who devoted their entire work life to a company. He is a wealthy man but I would challenge his views about our pay and profit sharing perks. I have been with GM for over 23 years. I think I got a profit sharing check once for about $200. We have had yearly reductions in terms of what we are expected to contribute for the few benefits that remain. Many US companies are forcing their employees to do so. Our jobs are going to India, Brazil and China and we were truly fortunate if given the opportunity to get an occasional 2-3 % raise in over 24+ months. We are forced to take our vacation time when GM tells us to, and a 12 hour work day is not that uncommon. As a global company, some people need to be in 4 AM meetings or stay super late. Most have cell phones and are on call 24/7. It looks like an airport coming in and out of work because so many people transport their laptops and their briefcase stuff on wheels. So I would say we are not slackers!

I can not address the pay and perks of executives. In the US it seems what exists is the “haves” and the “have-nots”. The US Executives pulled the “have” card and as they run the companies they sure compensate themselves greatly. The Home Depot $210 million golden parachute given to Nardelli is only one example. We see what the Wallstreet guys and Investment Bankers pull in. Maybe I just need to accept that the middle class is dying so rapidly there is no stopping it.

There is no doubt the domestic auto companies still must do more to restructure but it is not realistic to go bankrupt to do so. I would not buy a $500 TV from Circuit City because they are in bankruptcy. Are Republicans so out of touch? Remember the Bush/McCain statement that the “fundamentals of the economy are strong”. Well, we know what happened to them."

I'm not sure how to end this post, but I hope if you had any questions on which way to support this initiative, this helped you clear them up.

1 comment:

Kara Stutzman said...

You go, Girl! Note too that this is not simply national; it is global. The Big 3 provide jobs around the globe. Hits to them are hits to all of us.